📩 Fewer sign-ups, more hiring inquiries

A freelance email copywriter had a problem.

His free guide to writing better emails was pulling in subscribers. Plenty of them.

But none of those subscribers wanted to hire him.

They had signed up to learn how to write their own emails.

A veteran direct-response copywriter gave him a simple suggestion: replace the guide with a detailed case study showing how he had improved one client's sales emails.

That would give someone thinking about hiring him a look at what he could do for their business.

He built the case study. Sign-ups slowed down.

Then, within the first couple of days, people started emailing to ask whether he was available and whether he could do the same thing for them.

If you were only watching list growth, the new lead magnet looked like a step backward.

In reality, it finally started the conversations he wanted all along.

The veteran behind that advice has been writing direct-response copy since 2009 and, by his own count, has generated roughly $150 million for clients in everything from woodworking to joint mobility.

What struck me about his thinking is how little of it is about copy.

Most of it is about decisions publishers make before they write a word.

Who are you attracting?

What did you promise them?

And what are you counting as success?

In partnership with

When someone asks AI what to buy, be the answer.

Search didn't die. It moved. Your buyers ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity what to buy, and they act on the answer they get.

That answer is assembled from sources most companies have never looked at. If you're not in there, a competitor is.

ChatFeatured is the AEO platform that does the work to get you in AI answers: See exactly what AI says about you, and how you stack up against competitors on every major engine.

Ask the built-in analyst agent why AI skips you, and get the specific fixes. Publish content engineered to get cited, then watch every AI bot that crawls your site.

Vessel grew its AI visibility 2,200%+. Most customers see their first citations inside 7 days.

Start your free 7-day trial

_*Ad

Your lead magnet is choosing your audience

The first guide was not bad. It attracted people who wanted to learn email writing.

The problem was that the copywriter wanted clients.

The case study gave those potential clients something more relevant: evidence that he could solve a problem they had.

Every acquisition offer a publisher runs works the same way.

Someone who subscribes for a giveaway may have very little interest in your reporting.

Someone who signs up for a useful sample of your coverage has at least shown interest in what you actually publish.

Neither the download nor the sign-up tells you what happens next.

So look past the landing page conversion rate.

Do those subscribers respond to the newsletter they get afterward?

Do they keep reading?

Do they take the actions your business depends on?

A cheap subscriber who never responds is an expensive way to grow.

The promise that gets someone onto your list should connect to the reason you want them to stay.

Could another publisher sign your welcome email?

Most welcome emails could come from almost anyone.

Thanks for subscribing. We are excited you are here. Watch your inbox for valuable insights.

Swap the logo and nobody would notice.

"Anybody could have sent that email," as the veteran put it.

His fix: use the welcome email to introduce more than your name. Explain your philosophy, why someone should listen to you, and what they can expect.

For a publisher, that means answering a few questions while the subscription is still fresh.

What do you cover?

What makes your coverage useful?

How often will you send?

What is coming next?

If you promised a download, deliver it. If you promised a particular kind of newsletter, start showing the reader what that looks like.

Compare "We help you stay informed" with "Every Thursday, we explain one change affecting independent publishers and what you can do about it."

The second one gives someone a reason to recognize your next email.

"The more specific you can get, the more believable your copy gets."

You do not need a louder welcome email.

You need one that could only have come from you.

Become an email marketing GURU.

Is your email strategy due for a tune-up? GURU Conference (powered by Constant Contact) is back Nov 12–13, 100% free and virtual. You'll get email tactics you can steal the same day from top B2B and B2C marketers. Last year, 29,000+ marketers showed up. Save your free spot.

Register before Nov 12

_*Ad

He went to hot yoga to understand the customer

When he researched a hot yoga offer, the veteran went to classes for several months.

For a power generator project, he went to outdoor events and talked to people who might actually use the product.

That is a lot more work than skimming reviews.

It also gets you something reviews rarely do: the language people use when they are not sitting down to write a review.

"You almost want to think of it as becoming your audience."

Publishers have an edge here. We hear from readers constantly through replies, interviews, surveys, and conversations.

But it is easy to mistake the people who respond for the whole audience.

I see it all the time in publishing: readers say they want one kind of coverage, then their clicks point somewhere else.

That does not make the feedback useless.

It means you need both pieces.

Listen to what readers say. Then look at what they consistently respond to.

When the two disagree, investigate before you rebuild your editorial calendar around a handful of replies.

Proof can be something you show

When people hear "proof," they usually think testimonials.

The veteran's favorite forms are demonstrations and explaining why something works.

Picture an infomercial with a mop cleaning up a mess. You are watching the product do exactly what it promises.

A publisher can borrow that without turning a newsletter into an infomercial.

If your subscription page says you make complicated topics easy to understand, show an example.

If you promise useful local reporting, let someone read a story that proves it.

The case study lead magnet worked on this exact principle. It showed prospective clients what the copywriter had already done.

A subscriber count tells a prospective reader that other people signed up.

A strong sample issue helps them decide whether they should.

Let your work carry some of the argument.

Do not change personalities when you start selling

You have seen this one if you have read enough sales emails.

The writer starts out conversational. It feels like a person is talking to you.

Then the pitch arrives, and suddenly you are listening to a carnival barker.

The words get louder. The claims get bigger. The person you were reading a moment ago is gone.

Publishers do this too, usually when asking for a paid subscription or introducing a sponsor.

The editorial voice is familiar. The sales copy sounds like it came from a different business.

Your reader already knows what you sound like.

Keep that voice when you explain what is available, who it is for, and why it might be useful.

A paid subscription pitch can be direct without becoming theatrical.

A clearly labeled sponsor message can still fit the tone of the publication.

Selling should not require a personality change.

Find what’s slowing your GTM.

Most GTM problems aren’t one big failure. They’re one or two weak spots quietly dragging down the rest.

The free GTM Audit scores your go-to-market across four dimensions, then sequences a 90-day roadmap for your stage.

Drop your URL. Get your score in about 10 minutes.

Get My GTM Score

_*Ad

Five thousand past buyers, zero sales

The veteran also shared a project that went badly.

He had done successful work for the client before. The new offer addressed internet addiction, and the audience included roughly 5,000 past buyers.

There were reasons to believe it would work.

Instead, the project dragged on for months. Two decision-makers wanted different things. He turned down other work trying to finish it.

When the offer finally launched, nobody bought.

He received a $200 goodwill payment.

At first, he blamed the messy process.

Looking back, he questioned something more basic: did that audience want that offer at that time?

It is an uncomfortable question, because you can spend months polishing copy without ever answering it.

Ask it before you launch a paid tier, a course, an event, or a new publication.

Interest in your current newsletter does not automatically prove demand for the next thing you want to sell.

Good copy needs something to work with.

Follow the result past the click

A curiosity-driven subject line can grab attention from people with little interest in the offer.

A more direct subject line might attract fewer readers but bring in more of the ones ready to act.

If you stop at opens, you can end up rewarding the wrong email.

For publishers, it gets more complicated than counting immediate sales.

A newsletter might introduce someone to a sponsor long before that person becomes a customer, and the publisher may never see the eventual conversion.

So be clear about the role your newsletter plays, and agree on what success looks like before the report comes in.

Use the most meaningful outcome you can reliably measure.

Where sponsor data exists, learn from what happens after the click. Where it does not, be honest about what your report can actually tell you.

Remember the copywriter's lead magnet.

The sign-up rate moved one way. Hiring inquiries moved the other.

Which number would you want your dashboard to celebrate?

Put your best email back to work

The veteran's closing suggestion was simple: take a strong email you already sent and put it into your welcome sequence.

Publishers put real work into an issue, send it once, and move on. Someone who subscribes next month will never see it.

Here is what I would do this week.

Find an evergreen issue that earned meaningful reader response. Check the links, update anything dated, and slot it into the end of your welcome sequence at a sensible pace.

New subscribers get to read some of your best work while they are still deciding whether you deserve their attention.

Three things I keep coming back to:

1. Your acquisition promise shapes the audience you get. Before you blame the welcome sequence for weak engagement, look at what brought those subscribers in.

2. Specificity makes your value easier to believe. Show the reporting, explain the approach, give the example. Readers should not have to guess what makes your newsletter worth reading.

3. Your best emails should keep working. A useful issue does not lose its value because last month's subscribers already got it.

This is a guy who writes long-form sales copy for a living, and almost everything he said came down to understanding the person on the other side of the email.

Every publisher has to do that work, whether the next ask is a click, a paid subscription, or simply coming back next week.

Hit reply and tell me which old issue you are putting back into rotation. I want to see what your best work looks like.

GM.