📩 From Email Disaster to Black Friday Success

If you want to make real money during Black Friday, you cannot treat deliverability as a mystery box. You need to understand what happens when volume spikes slam into mailbox provider filters during the busiest email weekend of the year.

In partnership with

Find customers on Roku this holiday season

Now through the end of the year is prime streaming time on Roku, with viewers spending 3.5 hours each day streaming content and shopping online. Roku Ads Manager simplifies campaign setup, lets you segment audiences, and provides real-time reporting. And, you can test creative variants and run shoppable ads to drive purchases directly on-screen.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Use code GET5K now

1. Your Biggest Problem Is Not Your Copy, It Is Your Data

When deliverability falls apart, it is rarely because a subject line was weak or an ESP suddenly turned hostile. The problem is almost always the list itself.

Sloppy collection, stale segments, and ignored inactivity quietly drag down your reputation. Every year, brands pull their entire database into one Black Friday blast, including people who have not opened in a year and a half, then act surprised when inbox placement craters.

If you keep hammering disengaged subscribers, mailbox providers eventually treat you as a low quality sender, no matter how clever the campaign is.

2. Stop Obsessing Over Gmail Promotions vs Primary

Marketers lose a lot of time trying to dodge the Promotions tab. It is mostly wasted effort.

Promotions is still the inbox. People check it, skim it, and buy from it. When you try to force messages into Primary with tricks, you often train subscribers to complain instead of click, because it feels sneaky.

The goal is not a specific tab. The goal is predictable inboxing and stable performance. If opens, clicks, and revenue are healthy, you do not have a tab problem.

3. Authentication Matters More Than Ever

SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are no longer “nice to have” add ons. They are the minimum standard to get taken seriously.

Mailbox providers are tightening their rules and increasingly rejecting or bouncing poorly authenticated traffic. If your records are wrong, you may not even reach the stage where content gets evaluated. You are filtered near the front door.

On top of that, new standards and revisions are coming that will raise the bar further and reduce spoofing. Senders that already align domains and enforce DMARC will be in a much better position than those still waiting to “get around to it.”

If you have not checked your authentication in detail this year, do it before you increase volume.

4. Warmup Services: Helpful Short Term, Dangerous Long Term

Warmup tools can smooth short term sending changes if they are used carefully. The problem starts when they become a permanent crutch.

Mailbox providers are getting better at spotting fake engagement. If most of your “good” signals come from automated warmup activity instead of real subscribers, you are building on sand.

Long term, you still need:

• Clean, engaged data

• Reasonable frequency

• Healthy complaint and bounce rates

• Solid authentication

Warmup can support a strong program. It cannot fix a weak one.

5. Domain Reputation Now Matters More Than IP Reputation

If you are switching ESPs, this one matters a lot.

Your domain reputation follows you from provider to provider. IP reputation does not. That means:

• A domain with a poor history will not magically heal just because you moved platforms

• A domain with a strong record can change systems without starting from zero

Treat your sending domain like a credit score. Watch who sends through it, how often, and with what kind of data. The name in the From address is a long term asset or a long term liability.

Is Your Ad Spend Really Paying Off?

See how creator-led partnerships can boost sales with Levanta’s Affiliate Ad Shift Calculator.

Get instant insight into potential revenue lift, ROI gains, and efficiency improvements based on your current digital advertising strategy.

Run your numbers to find out how small shifts could drive big results.

Get your free calculation

*Ad

6. Cross Contamination Is Silently Killing Your Deliverability

Different teams inside one company often poison each other’s reputation without realizing it.

Common patterns:

• Sales firing cold outreach from the same root domain marketing uses

• Support teams blasting updates from a subdomain nobody monitors

• Webinar or event tools sending invites without proper authentication

• Legacy tools still pushing system emails that no one owns

Mailbox providers do not care which department pressed send. They see all of those messages as part of a single sender identity built around your domain and subdomains.

If inbox placement suddenly drops and nothing obvious changed in your main program, audit every system that sends email on your behalf. There is usually a forgotten culprit.

7. New Subscribers Are Your Most Sensitive Segment

New subscribers, especially in their first 30 days, are a highly sensitive signal.

If they open, click, or reply, mailbox providers see fresh, positive engagement and reward you. If they ignore everything, you get tagged as noise much faster than you think.

Treat this group differently:

• Run a real welcome sequence, not just one bland email

• Give early, obvious chances to click or respond

• Do not drop them straight into the heaviest broadcast schedule

• Hold back full volume until they show some interest

Even a simple experiment shows how stark the difference can be. Two new addresses sign up. One engages early, one never does. The engaged one keeps seeing messages in the inbox. The other gets shunted to spam much sooner.

New subscribers either help you or hurt you. Build for the first outcome.

8. Your Winback Strategy Is Probably Burning Your Domain

Most reactivation programs are built around a big emotional blast instead of a calm process.

The usual pattern: pull a huge list of inactive subscribers, send one or two loud campaigns, and hope a chunk returns. What really happens is a spike in complaints, bounces, and “this is irrelevant” signals.

A healthier approach:

• Automate winbacks instead of doing one time “events”

• Use steady, small daily batches

• Keep reactivation under roughly 10 percent of your active daily send

• Expect a modest recovery rate, around 2 to 5 percent

If your winback volume feels enormous or rushed, it is likely hurting your domain more than it is helping your revenue.

9. Inbox Monitoring Tools Are Useful, Not Absolute Truth

Seed tests and inbox monitoring can be very helpful, as long as you treat them as directional.

Filtering is personalized. One person’s Gmail does not behave exactly like another person’s Gmail. A seed list gives you a heartbeat, not a courtroom verdict.

Use these tools to:

• Track big shifts in inbox vs spam over time

• Catch sudden changes and trace them back to recent decisions

• Sanity check major infrastructure or list changes

What they should not do is drive every creative decision or send time. Let real subscriber behavior sit in the driver’s seat.

10. Black Friday Survival Checklist

Before you crank up volume, walk through this list:

• Start warming up now. Do not jump from 10,000 to 500,000 sends in a single weekend.

• Clean the data you plan to upload. Remove bad addresses and long term inactives before your biggest sends.

• Confirm SPF, DKIM, and DMARC are configured correctly. Test them before you need them.

• Ramp volume in stages instead of big spikes. Sudden variance is a red flag for filters.

• Tighten your new subscriber flows. Get early engagement long before Black Friday.

• Monitor complaint rates closely. Use tools like Yahoo Sender Hub to understand when subscribers are pushing back.

Missing even one of these can turn January into a month of damage control.

If you are planning to increase send volume by more than 50 percent in the next 30 days and you have not checked your authentication or list hygiene recently, this is the time to do it.

And do not stack your entire year on a single weekend. Spread your send volume across the season, protect your reputation, and give your email program a chance to keep earning long after the sale banners disappear.

Built for Managers, Not Engineers

AI isn’t just for developers. The AI Report gives business leaders daily, practical insights you can apply to ops, sales, marketing, and strategy.

No tech jargon. No wasted time. Just actionable tools to help you lead smarter.

Start where it counts.

Work smarter daily

*Ad