📩 How Clicks Really Happen

Master Click-Building Strategies From Top Newsletter Pros

Author

Captain YAR
September 26, 2025

Your newsletter design might be stunning and your content compelling, but without clicks, you have a beautiful digital ghost town.
This week, we break down how five powerhouse newsletters engineer engagement through smart strategy rather than luck.

In partnership with

It’s go-time for holiday campaigns

Roku Ads Manager makes it easy to extend your Q4 campaign to performance CTV.

You can:

  • Easily launch self-serve CTV ads

  • Repurpose your social content for TV

  • Drive purchases directly on-screen with shoppable ads

  • A/B test to discover your most effective offers

The holidays only come once a year. Get started now with a $500 ad credit when you spend your first $500 today with code: ROKUADS500. Terms apply.

*Ad

1440: Let Facts Drive Clicks

Trust builds clicks. 1440 proves this by delivering clean, factual summaries with seamless link placement. They embed external links within narrative flow, not as afterthoughts. Their "Etcetera" section includes offbeat curiosity-sparking content that readers can't resist exploring.

Steal This: Treat links like value propositions. Place them where curiosity peaks. When your audience trusts where you send them, engagement follows naturally.

Morning Brew: Gamify the Scroll

Morning Brew transforms clicking into entertainment. They wrap CTAs in wit, embedding links within jokes and pop-culture references. Their referral system drives engagement through tiered rewards like exclusive content. Visual elements become irresistible click magnets.

Steal This: Make every CTA feel like a conversation. Humor builds rapport, and when links become part of the fun rather than just function, readers respond.

The Hustle: Story-First Content

The Hustle leads with quirky headlines and viral-worthy copy. They build trust through entertainment, then smoothly transition to useful tools. Their sponsorships feel like insights rather than interruptions.

Steal This: Entertain first, educate next. Position your content as the obvious next step rather than forcing the pitch.

TLDR: Label Everything

Time-pressed readers love transparency. TLDR calls out read times and labels links clearly (GitHub, AI Tool, Blog Post). No mystery meat navigation. Their organized sections make discovery frictionless and rewarding.

Steal This: Treat links like value previews. Show readers exactly what they're obtaining. Clarity drives engagement.

The Skimm: Life Utility

The Skimm blends lifestyle content with practical utility. Their "But first" CTAs open each issue with curiosity-driven prompts. They wrap links in daily habits, making clicking feel like life planning.

Steal This: Build links into routines. When readers rely on your recommendations to plan their week, engagement becomes automatic.

Protect your checkout from coupon plug-ins. Boost your margin today.

KeepCart: Coupon Protection partners with DTC brands like Quince, Blueland, Vessi and more to protect your checkout from plug-ins like Honey, CapitalOne, RetailMeNot, and more to boost your DTC margins

Overpaid commissions to affiliates and influencers add up fast – Get rid of the headache and revenue losses with KeepCart.

After months of using KeepCart, Mando says “It has paid for itself multiple times over.”

Now it’s your turn to see how much more profit you can keep.

*Ad

Proven Click-Boosting Tactics

Structural Elements:

  • TLDR-style label tags on links

  • Curiosity links embedded within paragraphs

  • Progress-tracking referral systems

  • Navigation jump links for longer emails

  • Bold button-style visual hooks

Visual Approaches:

  • Clickable charts and graphics

  • GIFs that tease additional content

  • Emoji segment headers

  • Footer "View Everything" prompts

Psychology Triggers:

  • Tease enough to make clicks earn the rest

  • Create urgency with limited availability

  • Link to outcomes ("Add this to your calendar")

  • Invite responses ("Reply if you want this breakdown")

Engineering Curiosity Works

Click generation isn't about pushing harder. The most engaging newsletters engineer curiosity, build trust, and give people compelling reasons to lean in. They design smart engagement systems rather than hoping for luck.

The smartest publishers understand that every click represents a reader choosing to invest their time. Make that choice irresistible by embedding value, transparency, and genuine utility into every link.

Start with one technique. Test it thoroughly. Then scale what works while maintaining the trust that makes sustainable engagement possible.

Your boss will think you’re a genius

Optimizing for growth? Go-to-Millions is Ari Murray’s ecommerce newsletter packed with proven tactics, creative that converts, and real operator insights—from product strategy to paid media. No mushy strategy. Just what’s working. Subscribe free for weekly ideas that drive revenue.

*Ad