📩 How Ruthless List Hygiene Doubled Newsletter Engagement

Most newsletter operators know they should clean their list.
Very few do it in a consistent, disciplined way.

So they keep blasting the full list. Open rates slide. Gmail quietly nudges more sends into Promotions or spam, and eventually deliverability becomes the problem behind every problem.

In partnership with

The AI Race Just Went Nuclear — Own the Rails.

Meta, Google, and Microsoft just reported record profits — and record AI infrastructure spending:

• Meta boosted its AI budget to as much as $72 billion this year.

• Google raised its estimate to $93 billion for 2025.

• Microsoft is following suit, investing heavily in AI data centers and decision layers.

While Wall Street reacts, the message is clear: AI infrastructure is the next trillion-dollar frontier.

RAD Intel already builds that infrastructure — the AI decision layer powering marketing performance for Fortune 1000 brands. Backed by Adobe, Fidelity Ventures, and insiders from Google, Meta, and Amazon, the company has raised $50M+, grown valuation 4,900%, and doubled sales contracts in 2025 with seven-figure contracts secured.

👉 Invest in RAD Intel

_{This is a paid advertisement for RAD Intel made pursuant to Regulation A+ offering and involves risk, including the possible loss of principal. The valuation is set by the Company and there is currently no public market for the Company's Common Stock. Nasdaq ticker “RADI” has been reserved by RAD Intel and any potential listing is subject to future regulatory approval and market conditions. Investor references reflect factual individual or institutional participation and do not imply endorsement or sponsorship by the referenced companies. Please read the offering circular and related risks at invest.radintel.ai.}

The fix is not another subject line trick.
The fix is getting serious about who you actually send to.

That is the idea behind the Base Sending Segment, or BSS. Inside our media network, it is the single most important control we use to protect deliverability and grow engagement without burning out a list.

What Is a Base Sending Segment?

The Base Sending Segment is the smallest audience you can confidently inbox on any given send.

It is the tight core of people who are either:

• Actively engaging with your recent emails, or

• New enough that they have not had a fair chance to engage yet

Everyone else sits on the bench until they prove they still care.

This matters because email providers do not care about your subscriber count. They care about how many people interact with what you send.

If you keep mailing a large pool of unengaged subscribers, you train the filters to treat your content as background noise. That is when you see more throttling, weaker inbox placement, and in the worst cases, outright blocking.

Inbox placement is earned, not guaranteed.

How To Build Your Base Sending Segment

Here is a simple model that works well for a daily newsletter. You can tighten or loosen these rules based on how often you send.

1. Set your BSS rules

For a daily send, a good starting point is:

• People who clicked in the last 60 days

• People who opened in the last 30 days

• People who joined your list in the last 10 days

• People who replied to any email in roughly the last 90 days

Anyone who matches at least one of those conditions belongs in the BSS. Everyone else is suppressed for now.

If you only send a few times per week, you can stretch those windows. If you send twice per day, you will probably want to tighten them.

The principle stays the same: recency plus clear intent.

2. Send to the BSS only

Once the segment is defined, treat it as your list for regular sends.

That means:

• Suppressing everyone who does not meet the BSS rules

• Accepting that your raw send volume will drop for a while

This feels uncomfortable at first. It looks like you are turning your back on a chunk of your audience.

In reality, you are protecting the one thing that lets you reach anyone at all: inbox placement.

3. Watch your deliverability closely

A clean segment can still get into trouble if you ignore the signals.

Every time you send to the BSS, keep an eye on a few basics:

• Overall open rate, especially at Gmail

• Deferrals and hard bounces

• Spam complaints

• Unsubscribe rate

If those numbers trend in the right direction, you are rebuilding trust. If they slip, you tighten again.

Think of this like flying a small plane. You do not need a wall of screens, but you do need to know whether the nose is drifting down.

When To Expand And When To Tighten

Once your BSS is stable and inboxing is healthy, you can start opening things up again, slowly and deliberately.

If inboxing is strong, expand

You can begin adding back subscribers who have older but meaningful engagement, for example:

• People with at least 5 clicks in the last 120 days

• People with at least 10 opens in the last 90 days

Fold these groups in gradually. Do not drop your entire cold pool back in at once. The idea is to see whether those segments still respond without dragging down your signals.

You can also reintroduce previously suppressed leads in small batches, watch how they behave for a week or two, then decide whether they stay in the mix.

If inboxing drops, contract

If you see weaker inbox placement or a clear drop in engagement, fly lighter.

That usually looks like:

• Shortening your BSS windows

• Focusing primarily on the most recent clickers

• Temporarily suppressing any domains that are deferring you, then reopening those slowly once things stabilize

• Pausing experimental content or formats that might be confusing your audience until performance recovers

There is no prize for sending to people who have clearly checked out. Those are the subscribers training the filters to treat your work as noise.

Shoppers are adding to cart for the holidays

Peak streaming time continues after Black Friday on Roku, with the weekend after Thanksgiving and the weeks leading up to Christmas seeing record hours of viewing. Roku Ads Manager makes it simple to launch last-minute campaigns targeting viewers who are ready to shop during the holidays. Use first-party audience insights, segment by demographics, and advertise next to the premium ad-supported content your customers are streaming this holiday season.

Read the guide to get your CTV campaign live in time for the holiday rush.

Learn more

*Ad

What About Subscribers With Zero Engagement?

At some point you have to be honest about the people who never show up.

If a subscriber has not opened, has not clicked, and has ignored your attempts to bring them back, they are not really part of your audience. They are just weight.

A straightforward way to handle them:

1. Drop them into a final winback automation.

2. Make a clear, specific offer or ask in that flow.

3. Give them a simple, one-click way to stay.

4. If they still do not open or click, remove them from your list.

Yes, the number in your email platform will go down. That is fine.

You are trading vanity for deliverability, and deliverability is what gets your work in front of people who actually care.

A Real-World Example Of The BSS In Action

Here is what this looks like in practice.

A newsletter operator I worked with had seen open rates slide into the low range, and their email platform started flagging the account. The default approach was to keep sending to the entire list, mostly out of habit and a little bit of fear.

We put a Base Sending Segment in place.

Here is what changed:

• Regular sends went only to recent openers, recent clickers, and newly added subscribers.

• Sender reputation was rebuilt slowly, with close attention to Gmail performance week by week.

• The focus shifted from total reach on paper to actual response from real readers.

• Cold segments were only reintroduced in small batches after the core metrics looked solid.

At first, shrinking the active list felt wrong. It looked like a step backward.

A few weeks later, the picture was completely different.

The Results

Once the BSS had time to do its job:

• Open rate pushed past 55 percent

• Deliverability stabilized and held steady instead of wobbling

• Overall engagement across the list nearly doubled

The key detail is this: over time, more emails went to more people who actually wanted them. Not fewer.

That is how real growth works in email. You grow from signal, not from spraying the whole list and hoping for the best.

Before You Go: Run A Quick Gut Check On Your Own List

If your emails are not landing in the inbox, they are not doing their job.

A lot of brands blame everything from subject lines to timing while ignoring the obvious problem: they are still mailing people who stopped paying attention months ago.

The good news is you usually do not need a full rebuild. A handful of smart changes around your Base Sending Segment can be enough to get more of your email seen, opened, and clicked.

If you want a simple starting point, try this:

• Define your own BSS rules on paper for the next month.

• Send your main campaigns to that segment only.

• Track open rate, spam complaints, and unsubscribes for at least four sends.

• Decide which older segments, if any, have earned their way back in.

Give it a fair test window. By the end of it, you will know whether your list is built on engagement or on nostalgia.

AI that actually handles customer service. Not just chat.

Most AI tools chat. Gladly actually resolves. Returns processed. Tickets routed. Orders tracked. FAQs answered. All while freeing up your team to focus on what matters most — building relationships. See the difference.

Find out how

*Ad