📩 How to Hold Attention When Every Subject Line Looks Identical

A few months back, I watched a founder pull off a rare arc: start a scrappy daily email, sell it to a massive media company, buy it back later, and turn the whole roller coaster into a small consulting shop that helps other writers grow.

The throughline wasn’t a secret trick. It was discipline, taste, and a stubborn commitment to sounding like a real human.

Here are seven moves worth stealing.

In partnership with

Shoppers are adding to cart for the holidays

Over the next year, Roku predicts that 100% of the streaming audience will see ads. For growth marketers in 2026, CTV will remain an important “safe space” as AI creates widespread disruption in the search and social channels. Plus, easier access to self-serve CTV ad buying tools and targeting options will lead to a surge in locally-targeted streaming campaigns.

Read our guide to find out why growth marketers should make sure CTV is part of their 2026 media mix.

Learn more.

1) Track the signals that prove you matter
Open rates are a blurry mirror. The sharper picture is replies, forwards, and direct “this helped” notes. If you’re getting those, your email is landing. If you’re not, no amount of clever subject lines will save you.

2) Stop aiming for “professional” and aim for “recognizable”
The inbox is full of polite, well-meaning, perfectly safe writing. The easiest way to stand out is to sound like someone specific. Let your opinions show. Use the phrases you actually say out loud. If you wouldn’t say it to a friend, rewrite it.

3) Put boundaries around your voice
Creativity doesn’t die with structure, it gets protected by it. Write a simple style guide for yourself: how you open, how long paragraphs should be, what you won’t do. One rule I liked: entertainment is welcome, but it can’t hijack the point. A joke has to earn space.

4) Use AI for chores, not for identity
Let tools help with research, outlines, and repackaging older ideas into new formats. But don’t outsource the thing readers came for: your judgment, your tone, your weird little angles. If the draft sounds like it could’ve been written by anyone, it’s not finished.

AI-native CRM

“When I first opened Attio, I instantly got the feeling this was the next generation of CRM.”
— Margaret Shen, Head of GTM at Modal

Attio is the AI-native CRM for modern teams. With automatic enrichment, call intelligence, AI agents, flexible workflows and more, Attio works for any business and only takes minutes to set up.

Join industry leaders like Granola, Taskrabbit, Flatfile and more.

👉Start for free today

*Ad

5) Growth doesn’t have to be viral to be real
The clean path is: make the content work first, then add distribution. Partnerships, swaps, and proven referral channels can help once your engagement shows you’ve got something worth scaling. Paid acquisition can work too, but only after you’ve validated that new readers stick around.

6) Make at least one move that feels slightly uncomfortable
Incremental tweaks are comforting. They’re also easy to copy. Set a bolder target: a new format, a new segment, a cross-channel project, a collaboration with a creator whose audience is larger than yours. If it feels too safe, it’s probably too small.

7) Consistency compounds faster than cleverness
Most people quit early. The writers who keep shipping past the first ten sends build trust almost by default. Show up. Get clearer. Tighten the system. The inbox rewards the ones who stay.

If you want something sustainable, skip the hacks. Build guardrails, keep the voice human, and grow like you plan to still be here next year.

Can you scale without chaos?

It's peak season, so volume's about to spike. Most teams either hire temps (expensive) or burn out their people (worse). See what smarter teams do: let AI handle predictable volume so your humans stay great.

Check your options

*Ad