📩 How We Helped a Sport Blog Add 300,000 Subscribers

The unconverted traffic sitting on your site right now is probably worth more than your entire paid acquisition budget. Most publishers never look at it that way.

They should.

In partnership with

Find customers on Roku this holiday season

Now through the end of the year is prime streaming time on Roku, with viewers spending 3.5 hours each day streaming content and shopping online. Roku Ads Manager simplifies campaign setup, lets you segment audiences, and provides real-time reporting. And, you can test creative variants and run shoppable ads to drive purchases directly on-screen.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Use code GET5K now

The sport blogger who almost shut it all down

Nine months ago, I got on a call with a sport blogger who was about to shut down her newsletter.

She had done almost everything people say you are supposed to do. She had built up 250,000 subscribers. She published on a steady schedule. Her content was solid. Her recipes pulled in 2 to 3 million visits every month.

But one thing was quietly killing the whole project.

She was losing subscribers every single month to churn, and new subscriber growth had stalled.

Her opt in forms were converting at around 1 percent. On paper, that sounds acceptable, until you realize that means 99 percent of her visitors were leaving without subscribing.

Two to three million people a month visiting her site. Reading recipes. Saving them. Coming back for more.

And only 20,000 to 30,000 of them were turning into subscribers.

On the surface, that sounds fine.

Except she was losing roughly the same number every month to natural churn. Email changes. Unsubscribes. Inactive readers. People falling into spam folders.

So she stayed stuck at around 250,000 subscribers for more than a year. Not really growing. Not really shrinking. Just pouring time and energy into a list that was running in place.

“I have the traffic,” she said. “People clearly like the content. But every subscriber I add seems to be replaced by someone who leaves.”

That is when we decided to treat her unconverted visitors as the main problem to solve.

The math that keeps newsletters on a treadmill

Here is the pattern that burns out a lot of publishers.

You spend money or time to drive traffic.
About 99 percent of those visitors leave without subscribing.
The 1 percent who do subscribe start churning at 5 to 7 percent per month.
You end up spending more and more just to maintain the same list size.

In her case, those 250,000 active subscribers looked impressive on a dashboard.

But at a 5 to 7 percent monthly churn rate, she was losing somewhere between 12,500 and 17,500 subscribers every month.

To stay flat, she needed to add at least 15,000 new subscribers every month just to replace the people drifting off the list.

And that only kept her even.

The painful part is that she already had the traffic. Two to three million visits per month. The problem was not reach. It was capture.

What changed when we added a behavioral identity layer

Instead of trying to squeeze a little more performance out of her opt in forms, we added a separate capture layer.

In plain terms, we used a small script on her site that:

• Identifies anonymous visitors who behave like subscribers

• Scores them based on engagement, time on site, and patterns of behavior

• Sends only the highest scoring visitors straight into her email platform by API

• Operates within CANSPAM rules for eligible U.S. traffic

No co registration deals. No giveaways. No purchased lists.

We leaned on browser level signals, then matched those against a privacy compliant identity graph, so we were only pulling in people who were already acting like fans but had never filled out the form.

For this sport blogger, with 2 to 3 million visitors a month, the next six months looked like this:

• month 1: about 38,000 new active subscribers

• month 2: about 55,000

• month 3: about 67,000

• month 4: about 82,000

• month 5: about 76,000

• month 6: about 82,000

She went from 250,000 to roughly 650,000 active subscribers in half a year.

That is a net gain of 400,000 real, engaged subscribers.

All from traffic she was already getting.

Can you scale without chaos?

It's peak season, so volume's about to spike. Most teams either hire temps (expensive) or burn out their people (worse). See what smarter teams do: let AI handle predictable volume so your humans stay great.

Check your options

*Ad

Why the quality mattered more than the headline number

Adding 400,000 subscribers looks impressive in a case study.

What really changed her business, though, was the quality of those people.

Because we prioritized high engagement visitors, a few important things shifted:

• Open rates increased instead of dropping

• Click rates rose as well

• Spam complaints stayed low

• Deliverability improved because inbox providers saw better engagement

• Revenue per send climbed, and advertisers were willing to pay higher rates

She went from being stuck at 250,000 subscribers for a year to adding roughly 60,000 to 80,000 high intent subscribers every month.

No extra ad spend. Just better capture of the visitors she already had.

The list growth mistake most publishers make

Most publishers frame list growth in a very narrow way.

“I need more traffic. I need better opt in forms. I need cheaper ads.”

That sequence feels logical, but it skips the biggest opportunity.

If you are getting 2 million visitors per month and converting 1.5 percent of them through forms, you add about 30,000 new subscribers.

It also means around 1.97 million people visited your site, used your content, and then left without joining your list.

Some of those visitors will never subscribe to anything. That is fine.

But a meaningful slice of them are already acting like subscribers:

• They come back multiple times

• They read more than one article or recipe

• They spend five minutes or more on site

• They bookmark or save your content

These people are effectively part of your audience already. They just never got over the small friction of filling out a form.

The capture layer we used is designed to find them.

Why this approach works and why it is often overlooked

Most publishers sit on a huge pool of unconverted visitors and treat that as normal.

They pour energy into:

• ad creative

• landing page tweaks

• lead magnets

• pop up timing

Meanwhile, almost all of their visitors leave without subscribing, and that loss is just accepted as the cost of doing business.

A behavioral identity layer flips that.

You are not chasing more traffic. You are not ramping ad spend. You are finally capturing the people who were already there and already engaged.

Because the underlying identity graph is built on real engagement signals rather than scraped lists, the subscribers who come through that channel are usually:

• already familiar with your brand

• already consuming your content

• already behaving like active readers and buyers

They are warm, not cold.

The economics in plain numbers

Look at what this sport blogger would have spent if she had tried to buy 400,000 subscribers the traditional way.

Typical paid acquisition:

• industry average cost per subscriber: roughly 2 to 4 dollars

• cost to add 400,000 subscribers: between 800,000 and 1,600,000 dollars

• realistic timeframe: 18 to 24 months at a sustainable pace

With the capture layer we used:

• cost per acquired subscriber was around 10 cents

• cost to add 400,000 subscribers: about 40,000 dollars

• timeframe: 6 months

That is a savings range of roughly 760,000 to 1,560,000 dollars, with a shorter ramp.

On top of that, she saw more revenue per send from better engagement, stronger advertiser demand, and less time sunk into managing ad campaigns.

What this might mean for you

If you have:

• meaningful website traffic

• a newsletter or regular email product

• at least 100,000 monthly visitors

you are almost certainly leaving money on the table every day.

For many publishers, the real constraint is not traffic. It is capture.

The audience is already showing up. The question is whether your system knows how to turn those visitors into subscribers without asking them to jump through more hoops.

We are opening a small batch of strategy calls this week.

On those calls, we will look at your current traffic, estimate how many unconverted visitors you are losing every month, and sketch out what six months of improved capture could look like if you converted even 20 percent of that group.

If you are getting 100,000 or more monthly visitors and your regular opt in conversion rate is under 3 percent, it is worth seeing those numbers written down.

Catch them if you can.

The Future of Shopping? AI + Actual Humans.

AI has changed how consumers shop, but people still drive decisions. Levanta’s research shows affiliate and creator content continues to influence conversions, plus it now shapes the product recommendations AI delivers. Affiliate marketing isn’t being replaced by AI, it’s being amplified.

Download the full report

*Ad