- Grow 📧 Monetize
- Posts
- 📩 Lessons from Building a High-Performing Newsletter
📩 Lessons from Building a High-Performing Newsletter
I Burned Grands Trying to Grow My Newsletter
Captain YAR
January 08, 2025
If you’ve ever felt like you’re throwing bucks into the void trying to grow your email list, I feel it. I was there.
Spent 5,000 on ads that barely moved the needle.
Launched freebies that brought in freebie hunters instead of buyers.
Chased vanity metrics instead of capital flow.
But something finally clicked, and it wasn’t what I expected.
In partnership with
Improve your marketing with Ahrefs’ AI features!
Transform your marketing game with Ahrefs!
Ahrefs’ new AI features can supercharge your workflow:
AI Keyword Suggestions: Find high-value keywords effortlessly.
AI Search Intent Analysis: Understand user intent like never before.
AI Content Grader: Optimize content for top-ranking results.
AI Translations: Scale globally with ease.
Plus, enjoy free AI tools for copywriting, content creation, and more.
Start now and let Ahrefs be your ultimate marketing copilot!
Here’s what worked (and what I wish I knew earlier):
1. Focus on Engagement, Not Numbers
10 engaged readers > 1,000 disengaged ones.
Most newsletters fail because they chase size instead of quality.
For example, I once had a list of 5,000 subscribers, but only 100 opened emails, and I couldn’t sell anything. Then, I focused on building a smaller, highly engaged list, and my revenue doubled in three months.
Your focus should be on:
Getting buyers, not freebie collectors.
Building conversations, not broadcasts.
Creating proposals, people can’t ignore.
Lesson learned? Obsession with size kills growth.
2. Start Selling Useful Products Early
I waited 6 months before monetizing my newsletter. Big mistake.
Gratis content doesn’t build trust. Paid content does.
What worked for me?
Selling a 7 bucks mini-guide within 30 days that solved a specific pain point.
Offering an email course bundled with templates and swipe files for implementation.
Upselling coaching calls and group consulting packages to readers ready for more hands-on support.
Creating a monthly membership with exclusive tips, tools, and behind-the-scenes strategies.
The result? I made back my ad spend in weeks, not months.
2x conversions by pre-testing your ads? Yes, it's possible!
Get immediate feedback & optimize your ads with AI recommendations.
With Neurons, you can:
Improve content performance.
Make branding more memorable.
Run ad A/B tests pre-launch.
Neurons AI helps marketers get 73% CTR lift and 20% brand awareness boost.
3. Tap Into Existing Audiences
Growth doesn’t happen in isolation.
I started collaborating with:
Bigger newsletters to run swaps. Propose to feature each other's content and share audiences.
Creators to cross-promote guest posts, podcast interviews, or co-branded giveaways.
Communities to tap into engaged groups. Provide gratis value like toolkits or mini-trainings to become noticed.
The outcome? I gained 5,000 subscribers in 30 days without ads.
Don’t grow alone. Reach out to others with aligned audiences, pitch clear benefits, and make it easy for them to say yes.
4. Write Subject Lines That Spark Curiosity
Subject lines are 80 percent of your success.
What worked?
“How I Made 10K in 30 Days with Zero Ads.”
“Stop Wasting Time on Social Media. Here’s What Works Instead.”
“The 0.40 CPA Hack That Newsletter Gurus Will Not Share.”
If it doesn’t make people curious, it will not become opened.
There’s a reason 400,000 professionals read this daily.
Join The AI Report, trusted by 400,000+ professionals at Google, Microsoft, and OpenAI. Get daily insights, tools, and strategies to master practical AI skills that drive results.
Early on, I treated my newsletter like a fun side project. That mindset almost killed it.
Everything changed when I started:
Tracking ROI on ad spend.
Setting revenue goals.
Investing in tools to automate and optimize growth.
Once I made that shift, my inbound payments tripled in 3 months.
Your Turn to Build a 6-Figure Newsletter
Ready to grow faster and start monetizing your list? Don’t wait another month to figure it out alone.
Let’s make your newsletter unstoppable!