📩 Proof Beats Promises in List Growth

Last spring, a B2B software team showed me a weird chart. Their subscriber count was climbing every week, but replies, clicks, and upgrades were sliding the whole time. They weren’t “bad at email.” They were paying to add people who were never going to care.

There was no shortage of signups. The cost per name looked acceptable on paper. The real issue was intent. Most new addresses arrived cold, skimmed once, then disappeared.

In partnership with

Investor-ready updates, by voice

High-stakes communications need precision. Wispr Flow turns speech into polished, publishable writing you can paste into investor updates, earnings notes, board recaps, and executive summaries. Speak constraints, numbers, and context and Flow will remove filler, fix punctuation, format lists, and preserve tone so your messages are clear and confident. Use saved templates for recurring financial formats and create consistent reports with less editing. Works across Mac, Windows, and iPhone. Try Wispr Flow for finance.

Try Wispr Flow

The small rule that changed everything
They stopped sorting subscribers by where they came from and started sorting them by what they did.

Before, they accepted anyone who handed over an email from broad campaigns: giveaway traffic, generic downloads, and other low-friction offers. If an address passed validation, it got imported.

After, they added one gate: a verified email click inside related content. No click, no lead.

Prospects received a short message tied to the same topics the company writes about each week. Only the people who clicked through were added to the main newsletter. Everyone else stayed out.

What the numbers looked like
They ran a test with 2,000 click-verified subscribers. After 60 days:

• 1,759 opened at least one email (88%).

• 1,104 clicked at least once (55%).

• Of the people who clicked, 859 were still clicking at day 60 (78% retention among clickers).

• Cost per subscriber was $0.50.

• Only 12% churned over those 60 days.

That “still clicking” line is the part most teams never get. Usually, total subscribers go up while active readers drift down. Here, the active group grew faster than the total list.

Want to get the most out of ChatGPT?

ChatGPT is a superpower if you know how to use it correctly.

Discover how HubSpot's guide to AI can elevate both your productivity and creativity to get more things done.

Learn to automate tasks, enhance decision-making, and foster innovation with the power of AI.

Download the free guide.

*Ad

Why this flips the business
When you filter on intent up front, everything downstream gets easier:

• Engagement starts high instead of needing months to “warm up.”

• Retention improves because readers chose the topic with a real action.

• Revenue per send rises because funnels and sponsors respond to clicks, not raw list size.

A giant list that won’t engage is expensive baggage. It hurts deliverability, drags down your averages, and makes every campaign feel flat.

A simple back-of-napkin scenario
Keep the assumptions conservative.

If you buy 10,000 click-verified subscribers:

• Spend: $5,000

• Expected clickers: about 3,500

• Still active after 60 days: about 2,730

That’s 2,730 people who repeatedly raise their hand. Not one-time signups who vanish the moment the next shiny offer shows up.

The takeaway
A huge list is easy to brag about. A list that opens and clicks is the one that compounds.

Before you put more budget into acquisition, ask one blunt question: “Did this person show intent, or did they just show up?”

If you can’t answer that, you’re not buying growth. You’re buying extra addresses.

AI in HR? It’s happening now.

Deel's free 2026 trends report cuts through all the hype and lays out what HR teams can really expect in 2026. You’ll learn about the shifts happening now, the skill gaps you can't ignore, and resilience strategies that aren't just buzzwords. Plus you’ll get a practical toolkit that helps you implement it all without another costly and time-consuming transformation project.

Get the free report today.

*Ad