📩 Stop Focusing on Subject Lines

Most newsletter creators chase the wrong metrics.
The truth? Subject lines are a trap. They don’t tell you who’s reading. They just show you who’s curious.
You can’t build trust from a tap. You build it through attention. Through depth. Through repetition.
If you're still bragging about views, you're playing checkers. The pros are playing chess. Let’s break it down.

Sponsored by

Let’s get serious

Your newsletter, now exiting the stratosphere.

We’re beehiiv, the newsletter platform built for builders. Every product we drop and feature we create is made with one goal in mind: exponential growth. 

Our founders sought to bring the tools and tech to creators everywhere that helped turn their old company into a multi-million dollar operation. So when we say we can take you from “up-and-comer” to household name, we mean it.

If you need a beautiful destination for your content, use our no-code website builder. If you want paid subs, we don’t take a dime. If you want big name sponsors, we connect you with the likes of Nike and Netflix. 

In short: maybe your newsletter is stuck on the ground floor because your newsletter platform is stuck in the last decade. 

Level up and get started for free with beehiiv.

🧠 Depth Is the Metric That Matters

What’s more meaningful? A reader who skims your intro or one who reads every word, scrolls, and passes it on to a friend?
Depth means connection. Depth means influence. When someone finishes what you write, they start to believe in you.
And belief moves people. That’s what fuels real traction.

🔬 How to Track Reader Depth Instead

You don’t need fancy dashboards. Start simple. Scroll behavior (if on a blog): Are they reaching the end?
Tools like Hotjar can help you visualize user flow and interaction.

• Engagement: Did they follow a link buried at the bottom, not just the first one? Tracking tools reveal where attention lives.

• Replies: If someone writes back, they didn’t just peek. They engaged. They considered. They reacted.

• Direct feedback loops: Ask them short, direct questions. “What stood out?” or “Was this helpful?” You’ll learn a lot from just a handful of responses.

• Time between reads: Are they coming back? Are they diving into your older issues? That’s loyalty. That’s stickiness. Depth builds connection. People return not because they must, but because they’re drawn in.

🧩 The Psychology That Builds Depth

Most newsletters feel like a LinkedIn post got stuck in your inbox. No emotion. No curiosity. No payoff.
If you want people to stay beyond the first scroll, you need these three psychological levers:
🔥 Novelty – Start with something unexpected. A strange fact. A myth buster. A weird question. The brain loves contrast.
💥 Micro-tension – Keep a thread of curiosity. Every paragraph should raise a question that the next one resolves. That’s how binge reading happens.
🔗 Self-connection – Make it personal. Share quirks. Share missteps. Speak like a friend, not a brochure. This isn’t manipulation. It’s story. And humans are built for it.

Never Miss Another Warm Lead With Our AI BDR

Never miss a hot lead again. Our AI BDR Ava tracks intent signals across the web—triggering perfectly timed outreach when prospects are ready to buy.

She operates within the Artisan platform, which consolidates every tool you need for outbound:

• 300M+ High-Quality B2B Prospects, including E-Commerce and Local Business Leads

• Automated Lead Enrichment With 10+ Data Sources

• Full Email Deliverability Management

• Multi-Channel Outreach Across Email & LinkedIn

• Human-Level Personalization

Free up your sales team to focus on high-value interactions and closing deals, while Ava handles the time-consuming tasks.

Book a demo to see how Ava can 10x your outbound.

🧰 Try These 5 Prompts to Write With Depth

Ask ChatGPT one of these next time you're stuck:

1. “Write a newsletter opening that challenges a popular belief in my niche.”

2. “Summarize my last email in one unexpected sentence that triggers curiosity.”

3. “Rewrite this section using a personal story and a punchy lesson.”

4. “Inject micro-conflict and resolution into this paragraph.”

5. “Make this CTA sound like a friendly dare, not a pitch.”

When your writing feels real, it gets read.
When it gets read, it spreads.

🧭 Think Long Game, Not Loud Game

You’re not trying to “go viral.”
You’re building a rhythm.

The ones who last don’t burn out chasing the next hack.
They master the art of being read, remembered, and recommended.

What if you stopped chasing empty metrics…
and started chasing depth instead?

You might be surprised who sticks around.

You+AI=Unbeatable Presentations

Prezi AI turns your ideas into unique, dynamic presentations in seconds. No design skills needed, no boring templates.

Try for free today