📩 The $180K Problem No One Saw Coming

A team can do everything “right” and still watch revenue fall 40% in two months. Same content. Same schedule. Same list growth. Then the numbers slide, and everyone starts rewriting subject lines like it’s a fire drill.

In one case, the damage was already done by the time the finance dashboard looked scary. The business had quietly bled $180K while the real issue kept hiding in plain sight: fewer humans were actually seeing the emails.

Revenue is a lagging indicator. Inbox placement leaves clues weeks earlier, if you know where to look.

In partnership with

Write like a founder, faster

When the calendar is full, fast, clear comms matter. Wispr Flow lets founders dictate high-quality investor notes, hiring messages, and daily rundowns and get paste-ready writing instantly. It keeps your voice and the nuance you rely on for strategic messages while removing filler and cleaning punctuation. Save repeated snippets to scale consistent leadership communications. Works across Mac, Windows, and iPhone. Try Wispr Flow for founders.

Try Wispr Flow

Warning sign 1: Gmail looks normal, Yahoo looks dead
When Gmail seems fine but Yahoo performance collapses, that’s not “random audience behavior.” Yahoo reacts fast to rising complaints. If your complaint rate creeps above 0.1%, throttling can hit hard.
In this situation, Yahoo’s complaint rate sat at 0.31%. The team thought it was 0.10% because they were relying on partial signals. They optimized based on incomplete data, and Yahoo optimized based on the real number.

Warning sign 2: You’re blaming creative more than delivery
The moment you start asking “Is the subject line broken?” more than “Are people receiving this?” you’re probably late. This team spent weeks testing send times and copy. Nothing moved, because content can’t perform inside an inbox it never reaches.

Warning sign 3: Reactivation ‘wins’ on paper only
Dormant blasts that show high opens and “decent clicks” can be a trap. Look for patterns that don’t match humans, like clicks exceeding opens, or activity happening instantly. That’s often bot and security scanning.
If the spike doesn’t lift revenue or future engagement, you’re not reactivating people. You’re teaching mailbox providers that your mail is low quality.

Warning sign 4: Your “safe” segment keeps shrinking
If your engaged window is collapsing from 30 days to 15 to 7, your trust score is sliding. The typical mistake is pushing volume harder to “make up for it.” That accelerates the decline.
Here, the “safe to send” segment shrank from 275K to 145K in two months, just to keep placement from getting worse.

AI in HR? It’s happening now.

Deel's free 2026 trends report cuts through all the hype and lays out what HR teams can really expect in 2026. You’ll learn about the shifts happening now, the skill gaps you can't ignore, and resilience strategies that aren't just buzzwords. Plus you’ll get a practical toolkit that helps you implement it all without another costly and time-consuming transformation project.

Get the free report today.

*Ad

Warning sign 5: The list grows, but engagement stays flat
This is the most common early warning. Subscribers go up, sends go up, but opens, clicks, and revenue stay flat.
In this case, 80K subscribers were added in 60 days, and open rate fell from 42% to 31%. That’s not a normal tradeoff for growth. They spent $160K acquiring people who largely never saw the emails.

What the teams that avoid this do differently
They protect a truly engaged base, not “anyone who opened once.” They monitor Yahoo complaint rates in Sender Hub, and Gmail signals in Google Postmaster Tools. They track Gmail and Yahoo separately, because divergence is danger. They treat reactivation as a timing problem, not a blast. They use clicks and recency to make decisions, not list size. They only expand volume when inboxing is strong.

If any of this feels familiar, act while it’s still a trend line, not a crisis. Reply with “AUDIT” if you want a second set of eyes on engagement patterns, ISP divergence, complaint rates, segment health, and acquisition quality.

AI-native CRM

“When I first opened Attio, I instantly got the feeling this was the next generation of CRM.”
— Margaret Shen, Head of GTM at Modal

Attio is the AI-native CRM for modern teams. With automatic enrichment, call intelligence, AI agents, flexible workflows and more, Attio works for any business and only takes minutes to set up.

Join industry leaders like Granola, Taskrabbit, Flatfile and more.

👉 Start for free today

*Ad