📩 What We Can Learn From Cults

Building a Loyal Newsletter Audience

When you hear "cult," you probably think of manipulation and control.

But what if some of their tactics could ethically build a fiercely loyal newsletter audience?

Let's explore how to apply these strategies responsibly.

In partnership with

It’s not you, it’s your platform

Your newsletter content is top-notch. Your social media game is on point. Your aspirations are through the roof. Yet you’re stuck on level one.

We’ve got bad news (and then really good news): your newsletter platform stinks. And beehiiv can get you where you want to be.

Most newsletter platforms leave the growth and monetization aspects of content creation to the creator. But that’s like trying to drive a car with no wheels. 

Beehiiv’s platform is built for growth, so you can scale at the speed your content deserves with features like paid subscriptions, referral programs, and an ad network that connects you with global brands like Netflix and Nike.

It’s time to ask yourself: if your newsletter platform isn’t doing enough for you, what are you going to do about it?

1️⃣ Crafting a Compelling Narrative

Cults often revolve around a powerful story that gives members purpose. This narrative binds the group together and makes the mission clear.

🔥 Example: A newsletter that tells the journey of overcoming challenges can inspire readers.

🔑 Try this:

  • Share your origin story: Let readers know why you started your newsletter and what drives you.

  • Highlight reader successes: Feature testimonials or case studies that align with your mission.

A compelling narrative transforms your newsletter from mere information into a movement.

2️⃣ Charismatic Leadership

Cults often have leaders with magnetic personalities who inspire devotion. While you don't need to be a guru, showing passion and authenticity can draw readers in.

🔥 Example: A newsletter where the author's enthusiasm for the topic is palpable keeps readers engaged.

🔑 Try this:

  • Be present: Share personal anecdotes and insights.

  • Engage directly: Respond to reader feedback and foster a two-way conversation.

Authentic leadership fosters trust and loyalty among your audience.

3️⃣ Exclusivity and Belonging

Cults create a strong sense of belonging by making members feel part of an exclusive group. This fosters loyalty and commitment.

🔥 Example: Offering subscribers early admission to content or special editions can create this feeling.

🔑 Try this:

  • Create a community: Develop forums or social media groups for subscribers to connect.

  • Give exclusive content: Provide materials available to subscribers.

Fostering exclusivity makes readers feel valued and part of something special.

Unlock the full potential of your workday with cutting-edge AI strategies and actionable insights, empowering you to achieve unparalleled excellence in the future of work. Download the free guide today!

4️⃣ Rituals and Symbols

Cults use rituals and symbols to reinforce identity and unity. Incorporating consistent elements can make your newsletter more cohesive and engaging.

🔥 Example: Starting each issue with a unique greeting or signature that readers recognize.

🔑 Try this:

  • Develop recurring segments: Include sections that appear in every issue, like "Tip of the Week."

  • Use visual branding: Incorporate specific colors or logos that readers associate with your newsletter.

5️⃣ Defining a Common Enemy

Cults often unite members by identifying a common adversary, strengthening internal bonds. While not advocating for creating enemies, addressing shared challenges can unify your audience.

🔥 Example: Discussing industry myths or common pitfalls that your readers face.

🔑 Try this:

  • Address common pain points: Tackle issues that frustrate your readers.

  • Challenge misconceptions: Debunk myths related to your newsletter's focus.

Identifying shared challenges fosters a sense of unity among readers.

Final Thought

Your newsletter can be more than just content—it can be a community. By ethically applying these principles, you can build a loyal and engaged audience.

The question is—how will you transform your newsletter into a movement? 🔥

Never Miss Another Warm Lead With Our AI BDR

Never miss a hot lead again. Our AI BDR Ava tracks intent signals across the web—triggering perfectly timed outreach when prospects are ready to buy.

She operates within the Artisan platform, which consolidates every tool you need for outbound:

  • 300M+ High-Quality B2B Prospects, including E-Commerce and Local Business Leads

  • Automated Lead Enrichment With 10+ Data Sources

  • Full Email Deliverability Management

  • Multi-Channel Outreach Across Email & LinkedIn

  • Human-Level Personalization

Free up your sales team to focus on high-value interactions and closing deals, while Ava handles the time-consuming tasks.