- Grow 📧 Monetize
- Posts
- 📩 When a “Small” Market Isn’t Small
📩 When a “Small” Market Isn’t Small
A community-first fitness club that grew big by ignoring the usual playbook
Captain YAR
February 03, 2026
Most fitness businesses in small towns get boxed into the same story: limited population, limited growth, and constant pressure to run promos just to stay visible. The founder of a local running and wellness club didn’t buy that. They treated the town like a network, not a headcount.
In partnership with
Want to get the most out of ChatGPT?
ChatGPT is a superpower if you know how to use it correctly.
Discover how HubSpot's guide to AI can elevate both your productivity and creativity to get more things done.
Learn to automate tasks, enhance decision-making, and foster innovation with the power of AI.
*Ad
The results that sound made up
The club grew to 4,200 members across a rural region. Average acquisition cost landed around $0.30 per new member, mostly from referrals, local partnerships, and “bring-a-friend” moments that actually felt fun. The main touchpoint was weekly, not daily. One Saturday morning message with routes, meetups, and local updates. That was it.
The real shift: stop optimizing for sponsors
Most clubs optimize for sponsors first. More posts, more “reach,” more logos, more noise. This one optimized for members.
That changed everything:
The content felt like it was written for real people with real schedules, not for impressions.
Local businesses joined naturally because they were already showing up at group runs and meetups.
Revenue expanded beyond sponsorships into events, gear, and experiences.
Engagement stayed high because nobody felt chased.
The whole thing became a durable asset instead of a daily grind.
The guiding idea was blunt: if you treat members like a product, they eventually leave.
The simplest monetization move
Instead of selling complicated packages, the club introduced a small “community board” inside the weekly message. Think classifieds, but curated: a physical therapist offering a recovery session, a café sponsoring post-run coffee, a local shop promoting a shoe fitting day.
One week, that board brought in roughly $8K.
No ad tech. No long contracts. Clear slot, clear price, clear expectation. Businesses said yes because it didn’t feel like an interruption. It felt like part of the club.
Why weekly worked better than constant
The founder had a simple rule: if you message people every day, you’d better have something worth saying every day. Most brands don’t.
Weekly created anticipation. People knew when to expect it. It respected attention. And it pushed the club to focus on what actually builds loyalty: showing up in real life.
Keep pace with your calendar
Dictate investor updates, board notes, and daily rundowns and get final-draft writing you can paste immediately. Wispr Flow preserves nuance and uses voice snippets for repeatable founder comms. Try Wispr Flow for founders.
*Ad
In a world where digital gets deleted in a second, something physical can feel oddly special. Email is everywhere. A piece of mail is deliberate.
Why “local” compounds
Local growth is different because relevance is automatic. When you plan a meetup at a familiar park, celebrate someone’s first 10K, or highlight a new spot that everyone’s curious about, people share it without being asked. It’s not viral. It’s neighbor-to-neighbor.
The takeaway
Small markets aren’t small when you build depth. Community-first isn’t a vibe. It’s a strategy that makes growth cheaper, retention stronger, and monetization feel earned.
The best marketing ideas come from marketers who live it. That’s what The Marketing Millennials delivers: real insights, fresh takes, and no fluff. Written by Daniel Murray, a marketer who knows what works, this newsletter cuts through the noise so you can stop guessing and start winning. Subscribe and level up your marketing game.
*Ad